CHANGE LANGUAGE

Israel, three years since October 7: commemorations, protests, and demands for truth about the massacre

Three years after the Hamas attack on October 7, 2023, Israel is commemorating approximately 1.200 victims with minutes of silence and ceremonies. Protests against Netanyahu are taking place in Tel Aviv, while families are calling for an independent commission of inquiry into security failures.

Three years after the massacre of October 7, 2023, Israel pauses to remember the victims of the Hamas-led attack , while collective mourning continues to intertwine with the political, social, and military consequences of a day that profoundly changed the country and the entire Middle East. Ceremonies, minutes of silence, demonstrations, and commemorative initiatives mark the anniversary, while the families' request for full clarification of the responsibilities and flaws that allowed the attack remains unabated.

The commemorations symbolically begin at 6:29 a.m. , the time the assault began on October 7, 2023. Relatives of the victims and survivors return to the sites in southern Israel hit by the offensive, from the Nova music festival site to the kibbutzim near the Gaza Strip. The overall toll of the attack was approximately 1.200 people killed and 251 taken hostage.

Don't miss the latest news from La Milano: Add us to your favorite sources on Google in just one click.

Add La Milano to your favorite sources on Google

A minute of silence at the Nova festival

One of the most intense moments took place right at the Nova festival site , near Kibbutz Re'im. At 6:29 a.m., relatives bowed before the photographs of those killed, surrounded by flowers and messages. According to Israeli authorities, 378 people died in the attack on the festival, including 344 civilians , while another 44 were kidnapped and taken to the Gaza Strip.

La Milano Plus: subscription to read La Milano without ads, save articles, receive personalized news by city and region and email summaries.

That site, which on October 7, 2023, hosted thousands of young people gathered for a music festival, became one of the main symbols of the massacre. The attackers reached the area during a coordinated attack on Israeli communities near the Gaza Strip, while thousands of rockets were fired into Israeli territory.

Ariel Bibas's bicycle, a symbol of broken lives

Also telling the more intimate dimension of the tragedy is “The Space Left Behind ,” an exhibition that brings together objects belonging to those killed, kidnapped, or otherwise affected by the events of October 7. Among these is the small balance bike of Ariel Bibas , the red-haired child who became one of the most recognizable faces of the hostage tragedy.

Ariel was kidnapped along with his nine-month-old brother Kfir and his mother , Shiri Bibas . None of the three returned alive from captivity in the Strip. Had Ariel survived, he would have turned seven on August 5, 2026. The story of the Bibas family thus continues to represent, in the Israeli imagination, the familial and personal dimension of the trauma left by the attack.

Herzog lights a candle: "A memory that will never fade."

Israeli President Isaac Herzog also attended the commemorations. At 6:29 a.m., he and his wife lit a candle at the official residence, later posting a message to the victims on social media.

"Three years have passed since that terrible morning. Three years of pain, mourning, and a memory that will never fade. We bow our heads in memory of the victims, the fallen men and women," Herzog writes.

Remembrance is spreading throughout Israel. Ceremonies are being held in several cities, while some governments are flying flags at half-mast. At noon, the October Council , which brings together survivors and families of the victims, calls for another minute of national silence.

Tel Aviv, the Dizengoff Fountain painted red

But the third anniversary is not just a day of commemoration. Mourning is intertwined with protests against Benjamin Netanyahu's government and demands for accountability for what happened before and during the attack.

In Tel Aviv, anti-government protesters dyed the water of the Kikar Dizengoff fountain red , which in recent years has also become a place of remembrance, with photographs, flowers, and messages dedicated to the victims. A group of activists also briefly blocked the Ayalon Highway to observe a minute of silence.

Banners appeared with phrases such as "the people will remember their sons and daughters ," as well as messages strongly critical of the government, including "total failure." Around 1.200 human silhouettes were also placed on a Tel Aviv beach , one for each of the victims of the attack, alongside large Hebrew letters that once again spelled out "Total Failure."

Families call for an independent commission of inquiry

Three years after the attack, the issue of responsibility remains central. The families have long called for an independent state commission of inquiry to reconstruct the decisions made before October 7th and analyze the flaws in the political, military, and intelligence apparatus.

The October Council claims to have collected testimonies, documents, and official records over the past three years, and to have met with political representatives and security officials. The request is to examine the entire decision-making chain.

" Not for revenge, not for politics. For the truth, for the families, and so that October 7th never happens again ," the relatives say. According to the Council, three years after the massacre, the Israeli state still owes "a debt to the families": that of establishing the truth about what happened.

The “great failure” admitted by the military leaders

The failure of the security apparatus continues to represent one of the deepest wounds left by October 7. Several leaders of the Israeli security forces have acknowledged their responsibilities over time, including former Chief of Staff Herzi Halevi and former Shin Bet director Ronen Bar.

On the anniversary, Israeli forces commander Yaniv Asor also spoke of the IDF's "great failure" in protecting the country. The issue remains particularly sensitive politically, especially for Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu , who has faced criticism from the opposition and some public opinion for his handling of the situation before and after the attack.

Netanyahu and the impact of October 7 on the elections

The third anniversary falls at a particularly sensitive time: on October 27, Israel will be called to the polls for its first legislative elections since the massacre . The vote inevitably also signifies a judgment on the leadership that guided the country through the trauma of October 7 and the years of war that followed.

Netanyahu is running again after leading the Israeli government, albeit with several interruptions, for a total of 19 years, a record in the country's history. His candidacy is weighed down by the debate over what Israeli authorities knew before the attack and the signals coming from the Strip that were apparently not adequately interpreted.

The narratives and accusations published in recent years by Israeli and international media have become an integral part of the political debate. At the same time, the Likud leader's historic core of supporters continues to represent a significant segment of the Israeli electorate.

Tomer Tzadik: "I need to know why hundreds of people died."

The demand for truth also comes from survivors. Tomer Tzadik , who was at the Nova Festival on October 7, 2023, was 24 when he was seriously injured in the arm and managed to escape after a long escape through various hideouts.

Three years later, he says he began traveling to bear witness and argues that establishing an independent commission should be one of the first acts of the next Israeli government.

" It's part of my rehabilitation process; I need to know why hundreds of people have lost their lives. In these three years, no one has ever looked me in the face and taken responsibility or apologized ," he says. Regarding the rumors that Netanyahu may have received information about the risk of a serious attack, Tzadik emphasizes that he can't know whether they're true, but reiterates the need for an independent investigation.

The story of Maya Villalobo and her father's battle

Among the stories that continue to accompany the anniversary is that of Maya Villalobo , a 19-year-old soldier killed while serving at the Nahal Oz base, near the Gaza Strip.

The father, Eduardo Villalobo, a professor at the University of Seville , continues to demand that the attack be clarified. According to the family, some military personnel present at the base had observed suspicious movements and exercises in the Strip before October 7 and reported what was happening.

Villalobo has also waged a legal battle in Spain against the Hamas leadership. In his memory of his daughter, he emphasizes the need "not to lose what makes us human," while acknowledging how difficult it is to maintain hope after years of violence.

Former hostages and a life to rebuild

The third anniversary also brings the stories of the 251 hostages taken to the Strip on October 7th back into focus . The long-running story of the hostages has haunted Israel for years, becoming one of the most painful and divisive issues in Israeli society.

Several survivors have publicly recounted their experiences of captivity. Eli Sharabi, Aviva Siegel, Maxim Herkin, and Bar Kupershtein have also translated some of those experiences into books and public testimonies.

Others described the difficult transition back to daily life. Hagar Brodutch spoke of an "enormous daily struggle," while Ilana Gritzewsky testified before the UN Human Rights Council about the abuse she suffered during her abduction.

From October 7th to the war that devastated Gaza

The 2023 attack ushered in a new era in Middle Eastern history. Israel declared a state of war, called up hundreds of thousands of reservists, and launched a military operation against Hamas in the Gaza Strip.

The war also has a devastating toll on the Palestinian population , with tens of thousands of deaths and widespread destruction in the Strip. The conflict is gradually spreading beyond Gaza, involving Lebanon, Yemen, and the direct confrontation between Israel and Iran, transforming the crisis that began on October 7 into one of the most profound regional destabilizations in recent decades.

Three years later, Israel's memory of the massacre coexists with the consequences of the military response and the plight of the Palestinian population. These are two distinct dimensions, but now historically linked by the sequence of events that began that morning.

A country more to the right and more skeptical about peace

The trauma has also changed Israeli public opinion. According to a survey by the Israel Defense and Security Forum , before October 7, 31% of respondents considered the creation of a Palestinian state a potential disaster for Israel; three years later, the percentage rose to 52%.

At the same time, the share of those who believed it was necessary to reach an agreement with a “serious Palestinian leadership”, which had been reported at 52% before the attack, is said to have dropped to 31%.

Other findings highlight a profound sense of insecurity. According to research by the Institute for National Security Studies, 59% of Israelis believe that an event similar to October 7th could occur on the Gaza border in the coming years.

October 7 enters directly into Israeli politics

Trauma is even present in the electoral lists. Candidates include people who have lost family members, fought against attackers, or participated directly in the mobilization for the hostages' release.

Talik Gvili , mother of policeman Ran Gvili, ran for Likud , while the centrist front featured retired general Noam Tibon , who became one of the symbols of the reaction that day after heading towards Nahal Oz to save his son Amir and his family.

Shira Shapira, mother of Aner Shapira, who was killed while trying to protect others from grenades thrown by the attackers, is siding with Gadi Eisenkot . Sharon Sharabi , brother of former hostage Eli Sharabi and Yossi Sharabi, who died in captivity, is running with Yisrael Beitenu after being among the most active figures in the fight for the hostages' return.

Strengthened alert on the anniversary day

The commemoration is accompanied by a high level of alert. Israeli authorities fear that Hamas may attempt new actions to coincide with the anniversary and in the run-up to the elections.

Netanyahu claims that the movement could seek to use its remaining forces to strike Israel and influence the political climate before the vote, ensuring that any new attack would be met with a harsh response. Defense Minister Israel Katz also cited intelligence information regarding possible operations against Israeli forces.

The National Security Council also issued recommendations to Israelis abroad, urging them to exercise extreme caution in countries considered most at risk of attacks.

Meloni: "The spiral of violence must be broken."

On the third anniversary of the October 7 attack, the Italian government also issued a message. In a statement from Palazzo Chigi , Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni remembered the victims of the massacre carried out by Hamas and reiterated Italy's sympathy to their families, former hostages, and the Israeli people. She also commemorated the massacre with a reminder of the suffering of the Palestinian population in the Gaza Strip and the West Bank.

"Three years ago, on October 7, 2023, Hamas terrorist attacks massacred men, women, and children, attacked young people gathered to listen to music, and tore innocent people from their families to drag them into captivity. Today, we remember the victims of that barbarity and renew our closeness to their loved ones, to those who suffered the horror of kidnapping, and to the Israeli people," Meloni said.

The Prime Minister emphasized that "time passed does not diminish the gravity of those crimes" and added that "no cause can justify the deliberate massacre of innocents." For the Italian government, remembering what happened on October 7 also means "renewing our commitment against all forms of anti-Semitism."

The call to the suffering of civilians in Gaza and the West Bank

In its message, Palazzo Chigi then broadens its focus to the consequences of the conflict and the plight of the Palestinian population. "Precisely in the name of protecting all the civilian population affected, we cannot remain indifferent to the dramatic and unacceptable suffering of the inhabitants of Gaza or the growing violence to which Palestinian civilians in the West Bank are subjected," Meloni stated.

A position accompanied by an appeal to halt the escalation: "The spiral of violence must be interrupted ." The government therefore reiterates Italy's diplomatic commitment to reaching a political solution to the conflict that reconciles Israel's security and the rights of the Palestinian population.

Italy reaffirms the two-state perspective

"Italy will continue to work for a peace that guarantees Israelis security and Palestinians a future of freedom and dignity, with the prospect of two states living side by side within recognized borders," the Prime Minister continued.

The objective set by Palazzo Chigi therefore remains the two-state solution , coupled with the fight against terrorism and the protection of future generations. Meloni concludes by indicating as a vision "a future in which terrorism has no place and no child should grow up in fear and hatred."

Follow La Milano on our Whatsapp channel

Reproduction reserved © Copyright La Milano

×