Poland's Constitutional Court crisis escalates as government and president clash, with Nawrocki summoning political parties.
Poland, clash between Nawrocki and Tusk over the Constitutional Court: the Court's top officials suspended, protests in Warsaw, and urgent consultations with political parties.
Poland is in the midst of a serious institutional crisis, with an increasingly heated conflict between President Karol Nawrocki and the pro-European government led by Prime Minister Donald Tusk. At the heart of the dispute is the Constitutional Court, whose leadership has become the subject of a political and legal dispute following the announcement of the suspension of President Bogdan Święczkowski and his Deputy Bartłomiej Sochański.
The situation escalated on the evening of Friday, October 30, when the deployment of police forces around the Constitutional Tribunal building in Warsaw prompted a mobilization of supporters of the national-conservative Law and Justice (PiS) party. Protests continued into the morning of Saturday, October 31, while President Nawrocki cut short an official trip to Senegal to immediately return to the Polish capital.
The head of state denounced a "threat to internal security," announcing urgent consultations with representatives of parliamentary forces to try to restore institutional stability. The government, however, maintains that interventions in the judiciary are necessary to overcome controversies inherited from the PiS years in power.
Nawrocki interrupts his trip to Senegal and returns to Warsaw
The gravity of the events prompted the Polish president to suddenly change his international agenda. Nawrocki was already en route to Senegal, where he was scheduled to make an official visit, when he decided to order the presidential plane to return to Warsaw.
The decision followed reports of the suspension of the Constitutional Court's top officials and the deployment of riot police near the building. According to the Presidency, the evolving crisis required the immediate presence of the head of state to address a situation deemed potentially dangerous to the constitutional order.
Upon returning to the capital, Nawrocki began a series of meetings with judicial officials, including Bogdan Święczkowski and the first president of the Supreme Court, Zbigniew Kapiński. He then visited the Constitutional Tribunal, where protesters and law enforcement officers were still present.
Footage broadcast by local news channels showed the president walking through the crowd and reaching the building's entrance. The manner of his access to the courthouse further fueled the conflict with the government.
Urgent consultations with political parties to overcome the crisis
On the morning of Saturday, October 31, Nawrocki announced the convening of urgent talks with representatives of the parliamentary groups, with the stated aim of containing the escalation and finding a solution to the institutional dispute.
The decision was announced by the head of the presidential chancellery, Paweł Szefernaker, who outlined the president's position on the events of the last few hours.
According to Nawrocki, the situation not only concerns the composition of the Constitutional Court, but directly affects the functioning of democratic institutions and respect for the powers attributed to the various state bodies.
The president called for "stabilizing the political situation and restoring constitutional order," arguing that the actions taken against the Court's top officials had led to a particularly serious institutional fracture.
At this time, no concrete results of the consultations or any agreements between the political forces involved have been communicated.
The suspension of the President of the Constitutional Court
The episode that provoked the aggravation of the crisis was the announcement of the suspension from their respective offices of the President of the Constitutional Tribunal, Bogdan Święczkowski, and his deputy, Bartłomiej Sochański.
The announcement appeared on the Court's official website on Friday, around 18:00 PM local time. According to reports, the institution's leadership has been temporarily entrusted to Judge Anna Korwin-Piotrowska, listed as one of the judges recently appointed as part of the Court's renewal process.
The decision is part of the controversy over the appointment of constitutional judges, which has long pitted the current parliamentary majority against the President of the Republic and the judicial leaders linked to the previous political era.
The situation was further complicated by the emergence of conflicting communications through the Court's institutional channels. While the suspension was announced on the website, a contradictory reconstruction was circulated on the Court's X profile, according to which the portal had been taken under control and Święczkowski would continue to exercise his functions.
The divergent versions have made the situation regarding the actual leadership of the institution and the legitimacy of the acts adopted even more uncertain.
Nawrocki's complaint: "The constitutional order has been violated."
The President of the Republic has taken a particularly harsh stance on the developments in the crisis, accusing those responsible for the initiatives regarding the Court of having compromised the functioning of a constitutional body.
"This night, a violation of the constitutional order of the Republic of Poland and a forced occupation of a constitutional body of the state occurred," reads the statement attributed to Nawrocki and released during the demonstration in front of the court.
The Head of State also called for the restoration of legality and the withdrawal of security forces present in the premises of the Constitutional Court.
According to the presidency, the First President of the Supreme Court, Zbigniew Kapiński, also expressed a critical position regarding the initiatives undertaken, questioning the legitimacy of the people who took control of the institution.
The presidential statements confirm the depth of the conflict between the highest levels of government, with two opposing interpretations of the procedures necessary to ensure the functioning of constitutional justice.
Protests in front of the Constitutional Court and three people arrested
The institutional crisis has had immediate repercussions on the streets of Warsaw. Since Friday evening, numerous supporters of the Law and Justice party have gathered in front of the Constitutional Tribunal to protest Święczkowski's suspension.
The police stationed a security detail around the building, deploying dozens of officers to control access and prevent any intrusions. The presence of law enforcement officers contributed to heightened tension among the protesters.
During the protest, slogans were chanted against Prime Minister Donald Tusk, whom participants accused of seeking political control of the judiciary. Some protesters chanted "Tusk, traitor," while others denounced what they considered an attempted coup.
The mobilization also took on a religious dimension, with some participants praying while displaying Catholic rosaries and sacred images.
According to police reports, three people were arrested after attempting to enter the courthouse. During the tensions, some protesters reportedly climbed over the building's fence, while others threw objects at officers.
Even on Saturday morning, protesters remained in front of the court building, which was guarded by security forces.
Tusk defends the government: "Restoring the rule of law is our duty."
Prime Minister Donald Tusk takes a different view, considering the judicial reform process a necessary step to overcome the consequences of the policies adopted by previous national-conservative governments.
The Prime Minister reiterated that the government's goal is to guarantee the independence of judicial institutions and restore respect for constitutional and European principles.
“Restoring the rule of law is our duty,” Tusk wrote on his X profile, defending the government's line.
The prime minister added: "After years of lawlessness under PiS, this is a difficult, sometimes painful, process that requires decisive action. There is no other way."
The prime minister's words highlight the current majority's determination to continue reviewing the judicial reforms introduced during the eight years of PiS rule.
Tusk believes that renewing the Constitutional Court is essential to allow judges elected by Parliament to take up their duties and to overcome disputes over previous appointments.
The clash over the appointment of constitutional judges
The current crisis has its roots in the dispute over the appointment procedures for the members of the Constitutional Tribunal and the relationship between the executive branch, Parliament, and the Presidency of the Republic.
Following the Tusk-led coalition's 2023 election victory, the government began a process of reshaping the judicial system, which it deemed overly influenced by the decisions of the previous government.
President Nawrocki, politically close to PiS, opposed some of the majority's initiatives. In particular, he refused to allow the procedures for appointing constitutional judges appointed by Parliament to be completed.
According to the reported reconstructions, the head of state initially denied the oath to three of the six appointed judges, while further disagreements concerned the overall recognition of the new appointments.
Święczkowski, former Deputy Minister of Justice during the PiS governments, also opposed the entry into office of magistrates chosen by the current majority.
This opposition has progressively hindered the renewal of the Court, transforming a dispute over appointment procedures into a conflict between the main Polish institutions.
Anna Korwin-Piotrowska and the contested leadership of the Tribunal
A central role in the affair is played by Judge Anna Korwin-Piotrowska, indicated in the communications released on Friday as the new temporary president of the Constitutional Court.
The magistrate argued that the suspension of previous summits was necessary to "restore the rule of law," citing the need to ensure the functioning of the institution.
According to the Polish news agency PAP, Korwin-Piotrowska expressed her willingness to meet President Nawrocki at the presidential palace in an attempt to reduce tensions and find a solution.
His position, however, is contested by the political front close to PiS, which does not recognize the legitimacy of the replacement of the heads of the Court.
The conflict therefore concerns not only the people called to lead the Court, but also the authority competent to order any suspensions and to recognise the validity of new appointments.
Święczkowski denounces attack on the institution
The suspended President of the Constitutional Court, Bogdan Święczkowski, has harshly rejected the initiatives taken against him, describing them as a direct attack on the Court's autonomy.
Święczkowski spoke of a "coup d'état" and "an attack on a constitutional institution," contesting the ways in which his replacement was allegedly arranged.
According to the magistrate, the Court is composed of "legally appointed judges, not usurpers who entered through the back door accompanied by government security forces."
His statements reflect the position of the conservative front, according to which the interventions promoted by the current majority represent an undue interference in the autonomy of the judiciary.
The conflict between the two parties remains particularly complex because it involves the mutual recognition of institutional authorities and the validity of the acts adopted during the dispute.
The Minister of Justice criticizes the president's behavior
The presidential front's accusations were joined by the response of Justice Minister Waldemar Żurek, who openly criticized Nawrocki's behavior during his speech at the Constitutional Tribunal.
Interviewed by Polish broadcaster TVN24, the minister deemed the manner in which the head of state reached the building unacceptable, contesting the risk of further fueling political and social tensions.
“It is unacceptable for someone protected by presidential immunity to behave in this way,” Żurek said.
The minister then added: "For me, this is scandalous behavior, which exploits the situation to further fuel tensions in the streets."
The statements confirm that the crisis has now transcended the confines of a judicial dispute, transforming into a direct political clash between the government and the Presidency of the Republic.
PiS mobilizes supporters and Kaczyński asks Nawrocki to intervene
The suspension of the Constitutional Court's top officials has provoked a harsh reaction from the Law and Justice party, the main force of the national-conservative opposition.
PiS leader and former Prime Minister Jarosław Kaczyński spoke at the demonstration in front of the Court, denouncing the government's actions and calling for a response from the President of the Republic.
Kaczyński called the executive's moves an attempted coup against the judiciary, calling on Nawrocki to exercise his institutional prerogatives.
PiS considers the dispute a decisive step in the clash with the governing majority, arguing that replacing the Court's top officials would undermine the balance of power in the state.
The mobilization of party supporters could also increase political pressure on the government, especially if the demonstrations were to continue in the coming days.
The Origins of the Crisis: PiS's Judicial Reforms from 2015 to 2023
To understand the extent of the conflict, it is necessary to go back to the years in which the Law and Justice party led Poland, between 2015 and 2023.
During that period, national-conservative governments introduced a series of reforms regarding the functioning of the judiciary, the procedures for appointing judges, and the organization of the main judicial institutions.
The changes have sparked strong criticism from the Polish opposition and European institutions, who have contested the risk of excessive influence of political power on the administration of justice.
The composition of the Constitutional Tribunal, which is called upon to verify the conformity of laws with the Constitution and to rule on issues fundamental to the national system, has been particularly controversial.
The appointment procedures of some judges and the role assumed by the Court with respect to the PiS reforms have contributed to fueling a long debate on its independence.
The confrontation with Brussels and the primacy of European law
The dispute over the Polish judiciary has also had important consequences for relations between Warsaw and the European Union.
During the years of the PiS governments, the Constitutional Tribunal took positions that fueled the conflict over the relationship between the Polish Constitution and EU law.
In particular, some rulings have challenged the application of certain European principles in national law, provoking a strong reaction from the Community institutions.
The European Commission has repeatedly criticized Poland's judicial reforms, arguing that some measures undermine guarantees of judicial independence.
The Court of Justice of the European Union has also intervened in disputes relating to the organisation of the Polish justice system and irregularities in appointment procedures.
The tensions have contributed to the launch of European procedures and disputes regarding access to EU funding, making the rule of law one of the main issues of confrontation between Warsaw and Brussels.
Tusk's promise after the 2023 election victory
Donald Tusk's return to power in December 2023 marked a significant shift in Poland's political direction.
The pro-European coalition took power promising to strengthen relations with Brussels, restore judicial independence, and overcome institutional disputes inherited from the previous government.
The government's program placed particular importance on revising the judicial reforms introduced by PiS, which the new majority considered incompatible with some fundamental principles of the rule of law.
The implementation of this program, however, clashed with the powers of the Presidency of the Republic, initially exercised by Andrzej Duda and subsequently by Karol Nawrocki, both close to the conservative political area.
Disputes over judicial appointments and legislative measures have slowed the reform process, leading to growing institutional conflict.
The Constitutional Court case now represents one of the most delicate moments in this process.
US ambassador calls for avoiding further violence
The gravity of the events has also attracted the attention of the United States, Poland's strategic ally within NATO.
US Ambassador to Warsaw, Tom Rose, appealed to the parties involved in the dispute to avoid any behavior that could aggravate the situation.
“Do not take any action that could provoke violence or further escalation,” the diplomat said.
The speech highlights concerns about the potential consequences of institutional tensions and demonstrations outside the Courthouse.
Poland occupies a strategic position in Central and Eastern Europe, both due to its role in NATO and its geographical proximity to Ukraine and Belarus.
A prolonged internal political crisis could therefore attract further international attention, especially if the conflict were to compromise the stability of the government or the proper functioning of institutions.
A crisis that involves the balance between government, Parliament and the presidency
The controversy over the Constitutional Court highlights the difficulties arising from the coexistence of a pro-European parliamentary majority and a President of the Republic close to the national-conservative opposition.
In the Polish legal system, the head of state has prerogatives that can significantly impact legislative activity and relations between institutions, while the government is responsible for the political direction and administration of the country.
When the two figures belong to opposing sides, the exercise of these powers can become a source of conflict, especially on particularly sensitive issues such as constitutional justice.
The current crisis therefore also concerns the ability of institutions to find a balance between their respective responsibilities, without compromising the functioning of state bodies.
The debate over judicial appointments and the legitimacy of decisions taken risks further hardening political positions, making a shared solution more difficult.
Reproduction reserved © Copyright La Milano

